sender

mixoray

source

Unspecified

share



 



view


 Tree
 
 List


Illegal immigrants should all be deported.

cowrara

but

The cost of rounding up and deporting every single illegal immigrant immediately is more than the cost of allowing some to temporarily stay and work illegally.
sources:

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/trump-immigration-plan-cost-billions-experts-article-1.2978950

allersonyt

because

They arent counted as an american. this does not say ¨all Mexicans should be banned¨ it says ¨ILLEGAL imigrants should be deported.
Ardaa

because

They entered illegally and many of them corrupted the country.
Heywood_Jablome

but
1 but 2 because
2 supporter.

Why?
1 fallacy reported.
Begging The Question
thinkaboutit

but

Since you said "all" therefore only one instance is required to counter your premise. Initially all refugees appear illegal since often documentation is lacking. Also some arrive because our nation and our taxes have funded weapons and war in their home country forcing them to flee for safety.

sources:

Many immigrants complain that they did not want to leave their countries. They would love to have stayed in their homes. Indeed they love their homes but it has become too unpredictable to live and raise children due to war. The smart and wealthiest leave the earliest. Anyone would do the same. Who wouldn't!? It's quite hypocritical just to declare they should all be deported. So it depends on one's sense of compassion. If one is not compassionate one will "defend their country" and their comfortable status quo. If one is compassionate one will realize that the smartest thing in the long run is for all human beings to acknowledge responsibility for the planet as a whole.

n8n3k

but

If A allows B to stay on his property, than no one but A has the right to throw B out.
zifyduha

but
1 supporter.

Illegal immigration is a crime. A person who is convicted of it can be punished in more effective ways besides deportation, since deportees often immediately return. Since illegal immigration is often driven by economics, it would make more sense for the punishment to be garnishing their wages.
Disc

however
1 supporter.

Some countries could afford to give some of those immigrant the chance to resolve their situation with the country. Deportation could be used as last resource.
Disc

but
1 but 1 because
3 supporter.

There isn't an absolute answer
TheAbsentmindedProfessor

because
1 however
1 supporter.

I agree with this completely. The land belongs to whoever was there first. The only problem is, Native Americans might have difficulty running an entire country by themselves...
infinitely

but
4 supporter.

The only thing that differs inhabitants of a country from those who immigrated is the luck of being born in the right country. Thus, the only reason to deport illegal immigrants is their place of birth, which would make it discriminating.
dionisos

however
2 but
3 supporter.

There should not be any border.
Login or register to add a premise for this argument.