sender

qhett

source

Unspecified

share

view

TreeList

A creator must exist

‹ Go to parent premise
tinkerthinker

but
"Must" implies a lack of evidence, therefore it's an unreasonable assumption. One could just as easily say "Due to lack of proof, there "must" not be a creator". Both sides are weak. The question remains open, though good reasoning skills require us to err on the side of absence until we have proof.
gappleto97

but
Must doesn't imply this. If I find someone with a bloody knife, and a dead body in front of them, they "must" have killed them, yet we have reasonable evidence that they did.
OlieRendch

however
1 but
The Universe (and hence the fundamental environment, location, state and parameters on which it depends) must be such as to admit the creations of observers within it at some stage indicating intended life.
sources:

The Anthropic Principle

1 fallacy reported.
Begging The Question
Login or register to add a premise for this argument.