A state cannot deny unemployment benefits to persons whose religious beliefs preclude their working on Saturdays. | Intelligent Debating Platform | Arguman.org

sender

christinehamiltonbuis

source

Sherbert v. Verner

view

← ↑
↓ →

You can use arrow keys to navigate in the map.

Loading tree...

A state cannot deny unemployment benefits to persons whose religious beliefs preclude their working on Saturdays.

because

score: 1

The Free Exercise Clause prevents governmental regulation of religious beliefs.

sources:
Cantwell v. Connecticut

sender:
christinehamiltonbuis

9 months, 2 weeks ago

 permalink
- but
  
  score: 1
  
  The court has rejected appeals from the Free Excercise Clause to say that all religious beliefs are exempt from government regulation when considering public safety or peace and order.
  
  sources:
  Reynolds v. The United States; Prince v. Massachusetts
  
  sender:
  christinehamiltonbuis
  
  9 months, 2 weeks ago
  
   permalink
  - however
    
    score: 1
    
    The appellant's objection to working on Saturday constitutes no conduct prompted by religious principles that the State may regulate.
    
    sender:
    christinehamiltonbuis
    
    9 months, 2 weeks ago
    
     permalink
  - 0 branch
  - ‒
- because
  
  score: 1
  
  If the purpose of the regulation is to regulate religious beliefs than it is unconstitutional.
  
  sources:
  Braunfeld v. Brown.
  
  sender:
  christinehamiltonbuis
  
  9 months, 2 weeks ago
  
   permalink
- 1 branch
- ‒
0 branch
‒

%100 support rate

last update: christinehamiltonbuis (9 months, 2 weeks ago)