←
↑
↓
→
You can use arrow keys to navigate in the map.
Loading tree...
The Agricultural Adjustment Act is consistent with the Commerce Clause authorized to Congress.
-
because
score: 4
If the activity has a direct impact on the economy between the states, Congress can regulate it.
-
because
score: 3
Someone's personal consumption or disposal of a produced crop directly impacts supply and demand.
-
because
score: 2
Government regulation of price includes sustaining supply and demand which controls price.
-
because
score: 1
Previous decisions made by the Court allows the government regulate prices.
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
-
but
score: -1
Congress may not regulate production, mining, or manufacturing which are state and local duties.
-
however
score: 2
United States v. Darby (1941) set the precedent that intrastate activity can be regulated.
-
because
score: 1
Intrastate activity that effects the market in between the states can be regulated by Congress.
- 0 branch
- ‒
-
but
score: 2
The words alone "production" and "manufacturing" are immaterial to the matters at hand.
-
because
score: 1
If it affects interstate commerce, it falls in the realms of federal regulation.
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 1 branch
- ‒
- 1 branch
- ‒
The argument is too complex. You can switch to list view.
last update:
groendyk
groendyk
