←
↑
↓
→
You can use arrow keys to navigate in the map.
Loading tree...
Does rejecting Sherbet's unemployment benefits violate free exercise clause?
-
because
score: 5
the disqualification of unemployment benefits places a burden on the free exercise appellants religion. - yes.
sources:
Epstein & Walker pg. 381
-
because
score: 4
a law will be invalid if it is to discriminate between different religions.
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 383)
-
because
score: 3
appellants declared ineligibility comes solely from the practice of her religion.
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 382)
-
because
score: 2
Original ruling forces her to decide between her religion and forfeiting benefits.
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 382)
-
because
score: 1
government imposition of such a decision puts the same kind of burden on the free exercise of religion as a fine against Saturday worship would.
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 382)
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
-
however
score: 0
unemployment benefits are a "privilege" not a "right."
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 382)
-
but
score: 1
liberties of religion and expression may be infringed by these specific conditions laid out above.
sources:
Epstein & Walker (pg. 382)
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 1 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
The argument is too complex. You can switch to list view.
tarabarnhill
