sender

thecratecreep

source

Unspecified

share

view

TreeList

Everything in the universe is either a potato, or not a potato.

‹ Go to parent premise
zmt

but
1 supporter.
How about a fraction of a potato? If I cut a potato in half, it does not constitute a whole potato and therefore not **a** potato (but rather part of one), but, at the same time, is still made of potato, and is therefore potato. Therefore, it is not black and white.
dionisos

but
1 but 1 however
It isn’t because something is made of potato, that it is a potato.
Kataquax

but
1 supporter.
as you said half a potato is not **a** potato and therefore it is not **a potato**
Kataquax

but
1 supporter.
analog to your argumentation: argument: every set is the set of natural numbers or not the set of natural numbers. premise:how about prime numbers? it does not contain all natural numbers so it is not the set of natural numbers(but rather a subset), but, at the same time, it still [see sources]
sources:

only contains natural numbers, and is therefore **natural numbers** therefore it is not black and white

Login or register to add a premise for this argument.