←
↑
↓
→
You can use arrow keys to navigate in the map.
Loading tree...
Louisiana law does not infringe upon the 14th Amendment
-
because
score: 0
14th Amendment was meant to ensure equality between races politically
-
but
score: 1
not eliminate "distinctions based on color", or protect individuals in a social setting
-
however
score: 5
separation of races in public places does NOT mean that one group is inferior to another
-
because
score: 2
State "police power" is enforceable to separate white schools and black schools
-
because
score: 1
Law preserves social norms and preserves public order and peace
-
however
score: 1
Social equality between Whites and Blacks must come naturally and voluntarily, and not through legislation
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
-
because
score: 1
Massachusetts court ruled that schoolboards have ability to make exclusive schools for black children, therefore keeping races separate
sources:
Roberts v. City of Boston (1849)
-
however
score: -1
African-Americans are granted political equality, as protected and shown by the Supreme Court in previous cases
sources:
Strauder v. West Virginia (1880)
-
but
score: 2
This same concept does not apply to SOCIAL protection, or what happens in a local community atmosphere
-
because
score: 1
African Americans are not deemed equal to Whites socially, and therefore the Constitution cannot protect them at the same level as Whites
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
-
because
score: 1
"Colored" races are inferior because they give themselves that label
- 2 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
- 0 branch
- ‒
The argument is too complex. You can switch to list view.
jelsen37
