Argument Analysis Platform. Create and analyze argument maps online.

arguman.org is an argument analysis platform.

3 because 3 but 0 however

The denial of unemployment compensation infringed upon the Sherbert's First Amendment right to freely exercise her religion.

%54.5 objection rate

The denial of unemployment compensation infringed upon the Sherbert's First Amendment right to freely exercise her religion.

bringedk (4 hours ago)
5 because 2 but 2 however

Congress passing the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 did not count as a legislative activity that falls under the Commerce Clause

%100 support rate

It was in a local school zone with a student who attended that local school. They did not have any reason to believe he moved recently so it did not need to be classified as an activity under interstate commerce.

kinnanem (1 day, 4 hours ago)
7 because 2 but 2 however

Separate educational facilities for different races are inherently unequal.

%100 support rate

As the Board of Education of Topeka's policies currently state, there is no level of equality amongst all children.

munnje (1 day, 5 hours ago)
4 because 2 but 2 however

Protest and hate speech is shielded by The First Amendment (Snyder v. Phelps)

%100 support rate

Limiting/restraining a person's voice goes against everything the First Amendment represents.

lippinck (1 day, 12 hours ago)
4 because 1 but 1 however

Amendment 73 is unconstitutional.

%100 support rate

The Supreme Court believed that the Framers decided on the qualifications to make sure that it be steadfast and uniform throughout the nation.

nofferta (1 day, 13 hours ago)
2 because 2 but 2 however

The President of the United States has no immunity for civil law litigation for actions done before taking office or unrelated to taking office. Vote (9-0)

%100 support rate

Only 3 sitting presidents have been defendants in a civil litigation involving instances previous to their time in office but none comparing to the this particular constitutional issue.

raeanne27 (1 day, 15 hours ago)
3 because 3 but 3 however

Sherbert’s Ability to Freely Practice Her Faith Was Hindered by the State’s Restrictions For Unemployment Compensation.

%54.5 objection rate

Sherbert's ability to freely exercise her faith was hindered by the state's restrictions for unemployment compensation.

madimeyers (1 day, 15 hours ago)
11 because 0 but 1 however

National Labor Relations Board V. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corporation

%100 support rate

Furthermore, just because there has not been a disruption in recent years, it does not rule out the possibility from happening.

trolston (2 days, 8 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 1 however

Congress has the power to regulate employment conditions

Neutral support and objection rate.

Manufacture is not interstate commerce, the shipment of manufactured goods interstate is such commerce, and the prohibition of such shipment by Congress is indubitable a regulation of the commerce

alyssashoemaker (2 days, 10 hours ago)
5 because 1 but 1 however

Offensive and hateful protests by the Westboro Baptist Church are protected under the First Amendment

%100 support rate

The government cannot censor speech or expressions just because they are unpopular, or that society views them as offensive

jelsen37 (2 days, 13 hours ago)
5 because 2 but 1 however

Denial of Unemployment Benefits violates the First Amendment

%100 support rate

There have been no filings of fraudulent claims by claimants saying they cannot work Saturdays because of religious objections before the South Carolina Supreme Court.

rachaelsaxton (2 days, 17 hours ago)
4 because 2 but 2 however

New Jersey was not in violation of the Establishment Clause

%100 support rate

New Jersey was not providing financial assistance to the religious schools. Instead, they were providing the same transportation costs to all schools in the area.

rachaelsaxton (2 days, 17 hours ago)
5 because 2 but 3 however

Madisons refusal to deliver is illegal and Marbury's jump straight to the Supreme Court is unconstitutional

%100 support rate

Then the law must be discharged and it is unconstitutional to jump straight to the Supreme Court

minskij (2 days, 17 hours ago)
5 because 2 but 3 however

Congress has the implied power to establish a bank and federal laws are supreme over state laws

%55.6 support rate

Maryland taxing the bank violates the Supremacy Clause

minskij (2 days, 17 hours ago)
4 because 3 but 2 however

Schenck's conviction under the Espionage Act did not violate his First Amendment right of freedom of speech

%100 support rate

If the act, its tendency and the intent with which it is done are the same, we perceive no ground for saying that success alone warrants making the act a crime.

alyssashoemaker (2 days, 17 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 0 however

The State's Eligibility Restrictions for Unemployment Compensation Imposed a Significant Burden on Sherbert's Ability to Freely Exercise Her Faith.

Neutral support and objection rate.

madimeyers (3 days, 5 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 0 however

Amendment 73 is unconstitutional

Neutral support and objection rate.

nofferta (3 days, 7 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 0 however

Amendment 73 is unconstitutional

Neutral support and objection rate.

nofferta (3 days, 7 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 0 however

Congress has the implied power to establish a bank and federal laws are supreme over state laws

Neutral support and objection rate.

minskij (5 days, 6 hours ago)
0 because 0 but 0 however

Schenck v. United States

Neutral support and objection rate.

alyssashoemaker (5 days, 11 hours ago)
Load more