←
↑
→
You can use arrow keys to navigate in the map.
Loading tree...
the executive order did not violate the fifth amendment
because
score: 2
temporary exclusion of the whole group was needed
sources:
Korematsu v. U.S.
because
score: 1
there were members who kept loyalties to Japan confirmed by investigations
however
score: 0
exclusion of large groups of citizens from their homes, except under circumstances, is not consistent with our institutions
but
score: 1
when we are being threatened, we must be able to protect ourselves even if it means straying away for the norm
0 branch
‒
1 branch
‒
because
score: 2
Korematsu was not excluded from his home because of his resentment towards the Japanese, but because we are at war with the Japanese.
sources:
Korematsu v. U.S.
because
score: 1
the military feared an invasion on the West Coast and felt that this was the proper measure to take
0 branch
‒
because
score: 1
the curfew in the executive order provided inadequate protection and required relocation
sources:
Korematsu v. U.S.
however
score: 1
talk of imprisonment of a citizen based solely on his ancestry without any evidence is being spewed around
however
score: -1
if this were a case regarding a citizen being imprisoned due to racial prejudice, it would be a different story
but
score: 2
It is simply an exclusion order.
because
score: 1
without referencing real military dangers that were present, confuses the issue of racial prejudice.
0 branch
‒
0 branch
‒
0 branch
‒
however
score: 0
When the executive order was originally made in 1942, all threats of Japanese invasion were gone
but
score: 1
with authority from Congress, the military is able to say who should/shouldn't remain in threatened areas.
because
score: 1
there has to be trust that the military judgement was correct in knowing that there was no exact number or way to know how many disloyal members of the Japanese there were
but
score: 1
the hardships imposed on Japanese-Americans are not unnoticed
however
score: 1
Hardships are a part of war, and all citizens are going to feel the impact, whether it be small or big
0 branch
‒
1 branch
‒
0 branch
‒
1 branch
‒
because
score: 1
Congress showed their confidence in the military in a time of war, and determined they have the power to order this to protect the whole
sources:
Korematsu v. U.S.
3 branch
‒
×
The argument is too complex. You can switch to list view.
hunterfedewa
