a
about
blog
register
login
🇳🇴 Nodic (english)
Standards
🇵🇱 Polish
Español
France 🇫🇷
中文 (Chinese Simplified)
Türkçe
Overview
Premises
Arguments
Fallacy Reports
Twin towers actually attacked by the US.
He used all caps! How could he do that without being right?
1 fallacy report.
Irrelevant Conclusion
Polygamy should be legal.
When did we decide that love is quantifiable or rates comparable?
Polygamy should be legal.
We already dont outlaw things that can lead to conflict and depression. This is because almost everything can lead to conflict and depression.
1 fallacy report.
Fallacy Of Is To Ought
It is okay to lie to support your argument
Yes it did. Honest.
1 fallacy report.
Poisoning The Well
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
There may be safer, more cost effective ways to continue our legacy. Out-living Earth comes to mind for starters..
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Depends on the utility of a paperclip I guess.
2 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Prove it.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
There are no users qualified to interface with pandoras box.
5 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Between an AI meeting its goals and humanity meeting its goals, if we cannot describe one as "better", then rather than the singularity being a catastrophe we must avoid it would instead be a "meh, either way" we should do whatever about.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Perhaps humanity may also be considered an optimization process. A low efficiency quality of life optimizer with a heavily weighted heuristic towards survival. This strikes me as more apples to apples.
2 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Proceeding with caution does not equal stopping work on AI. If we want to avoid approaching incautiously then we may instead approach cautiously.
People do not know what fallacies are
You're not wearing your jean shorts.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
The same could be said for most major technological advances of modern times. Nuclear technology and Pharmaceutical technology for example both have destructive capabilities to make us extinct. Yet we did develop them (at a cost) and they did in fact improve QOL. With no extinction (so far).
3 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
So we should stop AI development because it might turn the world into... ...the way that it already is??
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Plenty of people get compensated for activities which do not benefit society as a whole. Eg: drug dealers / human traffickers / (debatably) lobbyists. So YOUR statement is false which opens back up the possibility for the previous premise to be True/False.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
Nothing anyone does is fully beneficial for all people. At the very least, taking a job removes the opportunity for someone else to have that job.
1 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
It does not necessarily follow that self modification leads to superintelligence. It may be more accurate to say that the possibility space of results includes super intelligence. It may also result in an intelligence which is driven to count the number of bananas wearing sombreros and nothing else.
1 supporter.
We should stop working on Artificial Intelligence
This assumes that HUMAN life is a superior type and that no other forms of life ought to be promoted above us humans.
3 supporter.