Irrelevant Conclusion

We are talking about the risk/possibility of resources consumed excessively by making them as common goods when shared to poor countries, not whether by default resources are abundant in one place and lacking in the other places.

Pragmatic Fallacy

Might be a fallacy since the standard used to judge the concept "works" is a belief that it is going to make X (life) not Y (boring--which seems vague here).

Fallacy Of Irrelevant Purpose

Missing the point. It does not address the question.