We should remove (or significantly limit) the taxexemption for private charitable donations
because
score: 1
Tax deductions for charity give the IRS the power to decide what qualifies as a charity and what doesn't. The IRS can abuse this power, as it has for example to disqualify Tea Party organizations.
In many issues there are charities on both sides, fighting a zero sum game, for example pro-choice and pro-life charities. If they both have less money the end result in policies being enacted probably won't be any different.
This argument seems to frame 'not paying as much tax' as 'taking from (other) taxpayers/society" which seems to presuppose the moral legitimacy of taxation in a very strong (and controversial) way.
From a consequentialist point of view, this is only "bad" if the expected social value of private donations is lower than the expected social value of tax revenue
Tax exemptions create legal complexity and distort incentives (e.g. big 4 have tax minimisation service lines which is a waste of money and talent). Getting rid of all tax exemptions is a good idea, and removing the charity exemption is a step in this direction.
anti_realist
